Winner: I was just wild about this gown on Olivia Wilde. She was the picture of perfection. The color was jut gorgeous and really showcased the beautiful workmanship of the gown. It also looks better on a smaller frame.
Winner: To be honest, they should both lose because this dress is a loser, but if I had to pick a winner it would be Lake Bell. Why? First of all Taraji found herself on our WTF Was She Thinking? crimes of fashion list in this dress. Just look at her chest and you can see why. She is busting out of it and this dress is not meant to be busted out of.
Winner: Rihanna. The color was beautiful on her skintone and the style accentuated her figure. Rosario thankfully wore a deep red lipstick, but it wasn't enough to save her.
Winner: To be fair this is a horrible picture of Lindsay. Even so, she wins. I prefer her shoe choice over the strappy little silver number Jennifer wore. It's winter dress and should be paired with a winter shoe. I also think the multi-strand pearls are a but much when the skirt of the dress has enough detail. It competes.
Winner: Diane Kruger. She loses points for the messy hairstyle, but makes them up with her paring of ruby red pumps. The ivory color of the dress really accentuates the Mad Men like style. Marisa's all black ensemble with tightly pulled back hair looks too severe.
Winner: Kate Bosworth. To be honest, I don't know if I would ever pick half of Speidi, but I do prefer Kate's gorgeous sandals and the pairing with an of-the-moment blazer. Heidi looks dated. Amazing considering she is all of what, 22?
Winner: This is a tough one. When I first saw Salma in this dress I thought she looked stunning, but if I had to pick a winner it would be Amanda. Simply pulled back hair played off the gown better. Salma overdid the look a bit. Honestly, however…I think they both look great.
– Lauren Dimet Waters
Photos: People.comSee the Top Ten Summer 2016 Trends for Women Over 40
Tags: 3.1 Phillip Lim, Amanda Seyfried, Beyonce, celebrities, celebrity smackdown, celebrity style, Chloe, Diane Kruger, Dolce & Gabbana, dress, Giambattista Valli, Heidi Montag, Jennifer Morrison, Kate Bosworth, Kaufman Franco, Lake Bell, Lauren Dimet Waters, Lindsay Price, Marisa Tomei, Olivia Wilde, red carpaet, Reem Acra, Rihanna, Rosario Dawson, Salma Hayek, shorts, Stella McCartney, Taraji P. Henson, who wore it better