Hilary Duff vs. Hayden Panettiere in Crispin & Basilio
Winner: Hilary. I’m all for a color other than black, but the shoes and the bag Hayden chose were too matchy-matchy, not to mention the dress is unflattering on her.
Fergielicious vs. Eva Longoria in the trenches in Juicy Couture
Winner: Fergie. I can’t believe this result, but the normally scantily clad singer pulled out a put together ensemble in comparison to Eva’s more casual jeans look. A skinny leg darker jean may have resulted differently.
The totally cute Juicy Couture Cotton Twill Trench Coat with Piping is available for $350 at Nordstrom.com
Claudia Schiffer vs. Lindsay Lohan in Chanel
Winner: Lohan. Another upset! Who would have thought the supermodel would lose? However, Schiffer’s opaque black tights and too short hem were no match for Lindsay’s smokin’ pumps.
Mary Lynn Rajskub vs. Paula Patton in Sass & Bide
Winner: Who are these women? Neither hit this one out of the park, but tights with flats in that sexy dress? The boots were moderately better, therefore making Patton the winner, but a sexy strappy high-heeled sandal in any color but black would have been the best choice.