Emma Roberts vs. Sarah Jessica Parker in Alice & Olivia
Winner: Sarah Jessica Parker. She may have a bummer fashion line (Bitten), but SJP rises to the occasion in this sequined, chevron number. Emma’s shoe choice along with chopping off the cute cap sleeve, make her look much older than (a girl of 17?) a young woman should.
Chelsea Clinton vs. JLo in Oscar de la Renta
Winner: No contest, this was a give-me. If you still don’t know, it’s JLo, duh. It doesn’t even look like the same dress does it? The fit is much better on JLo for starters. Had Chelsea raised the hem and gone sans sheer black hose (ew), she might have been a contender. OK, maybe not.
Jamie King vs. Daphne Rubin-Vega in Cynthia Rowley
Winner: Daphne Rubin-Vega. This is a prime example of how baby-doll dresses get tricky. When I first viewed the one on the left (Jamie King) I hated the dress (I still hate the sandals, by the way), she looks heavy! However, when you see the dress a little longer and cinched in at the waist…it’s great!